Skip to main content

Video shows former county officer who pleaded guilty to dragging teen by hair, handcuffs


Video shows former county officer who pleaded guilty to dragging teen by hair, handcuffs

A former New Castle County police corporal who pleaded guilty to repeatedly pulling a 16-year-old girl's hair and dragging her by the handcuffs while she's on her stomach last year has been sentenced to one year of probation.

Michael Carnevale, whose probation will be suspended upon completion of anger management courses, community service and the surrender of his police training certificate, declined to comment following his sentencing Thursday afternoon at the Leonard L. Williams Justice Center in Wilmington. The 46-year-old wore khaki pants, a striped button-down shirt and sported a beard as he left the courtroom with his attorney.

On Thursday, New Castle County police released two video clips showing then-Cpl. Carnevale dragging the girl from the chain of the handcuffs fastened behind her back. The girl, who is resisting, appears to have fallen before Carnevale starts dragging her while she's on her stomach. A second clip also shows him dragging the girl to a holding room before she drops to the ground. He is then joined by another officer who helps shove her into the room.

The video was not previously released because of the pending investigation.

"The actions of Mr. Carnevale seen in the video are not within the policies and procedures of the New Castle County Police and do not reflect the values and standards of the division," Col. Joseph Bloch, county police chief, said in a statement. "Although I am disgusted that this incident took place, I am pleased that through the hard work of the Department of Justice – Division of Civil Rights and Public Trust and our internal investigators, Mr. Carnevale was held accountable for his actions and will never serve in law enforcement again. "

Carnevale also agreed to never seek employment or serve in a law enforcement capacity in the future.

"The New Castle County Division of Police prides itself on the relationships we have built within the communities we serve," Bloch said. "I am hopeful that our immediate response to this incident demonstrates our commitment to holding ourselves accountable and builds upon the public trust that we have established over many years of dedicated service."

The investigation into Carnevale's actions began on Aug. 31 after a fellow officer witnessed the excessive use of force and reported it to a commander, county police said. 

According to a separate Delaware Department of Justice release, the incident occurred on Aug. 30 when the girl became disorderly and resistant while she was at the police station.

"The evidence revealed that Carnevale repeatedly pulled and attempted to lift the victim by her hair, and dragged her in a prone position nearly 50 feet along the ground by the chain of the handcuffs fastened behind her back," the Justice Department's statement said. 

Carnevale, who had been with the department since 2005, completed a single-page crime report detailing a video arraignment, but did not mention any resistance by the victim or any police use of force, the Justice Department said. Carnevale also did not complete a use-of-force report.

Carnevale was suspended pending the outcome of the internal investigation and retired from the Police Department on Oct. 3 — prior to the end of the department's investigation and before any disciplinary action could be taken.

The former officer was indicted in December on three misdemeanor charges: offensive touching, official misconduct and falsifying business records.

He pleaded guilty to offensive touching, which carried a maximum sentence of 30 days in prison and a fine. His other charges were dismissed in exchange for his guilty plea, which occurred a few days before his trial was scheduled to start on Monday.

His sentence came immediately after he pleaded guilty on Thursday.

Carnevale's indictment was among the first of several incidents in which a string of Delaware officers have been charged with crimes while they were on the job.

Many of these prosecutions are being led by Mark Denney, who is the director of the Division of Civil Rights and Public Trust at the Delaware Department of Justice.

A few months after Carnevale's December indictment, the Delaware Department of Justice indicted former Wilmington police officer Samuel Waters with eight crimes, including two felonies: tampering with public records and perjury. Also indicted in March was another former Wilmington officer, Brandon Cooper, who faces charges of sexual solicitation of a child.

"We continue to be proud of the kind of work that the Division of Civil Rights and Public Trust is doing with minimal resources," Mat Marshall, a Justice Department spokesman, said on Thursday. "Above all else we are thinking of the victim and the victim's family today." 

Advocates of police transparency say Carnevale's case is an example of why Delaware's Law Enforcement Officers' Bill of Rights, also known as LEOBOR, needs to be revised.

"Certainly we are happy that this incident was investigated, that the officer was indicted and eventually pled guilty to this assault on the 16-year-old young woman," said Mike Brickner, ACLU of Delaware's executive director. "But we also know that there is really a lack of transparency around these policing issues that Delaware's LEOBOR law is the most extreme in the country when it comes to transparency.

"Members of the public just do not have a right to information about police disciplinary matters."

LEOBOR requires that police disciplinary actions in Delaware be kept secret from public disclosure. In many cases, the public learns of these incidents only from civil lawsuits, where citizens sue police for causing physical injury or damages.

While charges were announced against Carnevale, it took the public a little over three months to learn something had occurred — that was after he was indicted.

Other states allow for there to be public records requests from regular citizens or watchdog organizations like the ACLU, Brickner said. This transparency gives the public a sense of what is occurring in its police department and that something is being looked at or done.

Other jurisdictions that do, especially those that have community oversight boards, they do things like periodically report out data and other statistics, how many police disciplinary cases there have been," he said. "Again, we just don't know that information here in Delaware because so much of it is secret and generally law enforcement is not out there proactively sharing that information."

Delaware lawmakers have proposed revising LEOBOR twice, but their efforts have gone nowhere.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A graduate in Biology was having difficulty in finding a job. He saw an advert in one of the daily newspapers for a job at a zoo.🗞️👀

  A graduate in Biology was having difficulty in finding a job. He saw an advert in one of the daily newspapers for a job at a zoo.🗞️👀 In the interview, the manager told him that their gorilla🦍, which had been a tourists attraction has died so they needed someone to dress up and pretend as a gorilla🦍.  The graduate was embarra$$ed, but since the salary was okay, he accepted the job. The first day, he put on the gorilla skin and entered the cage, he started jumping up and down, beating his chest and roared like a gorilla.  The next day, he put on a gorilla skin and started moving around the zoo again and mistakenly entered another cage and found himself staring at a lion🦁.  The lion r0ared and rushed towards him. The scared graduate quickly forgot that he is a g0rilla and started shouting like a human, 🗣️"Help! Help!" The lion leaped onto him, knocked him to the ground and whispered in his ear👂*Dennis*, it's me Mike, your course mate." My brother, No job in thi...

Cynthia Rothrock as Terry:

In No Retreat, No Surrender 2 (1987), Cynthia Rothrock plays a significant role, adding her martial arts prowess to the film’s dynamic action sequences. Character and Role: • Cynthia Rothrock as Terry: • Cynthia Rothrock portrays Terry, a tough and skilled martial artist who teams up with Scott Wylde (played by Loren Avedon) and Mac Jarvis (played by Max Thayer) on their mission to rescue Scott’s kidnapped girlfriend. Terry is not only a fierce fighter but also a loyal and dependable friend, contributing significantly to the team’s efforts throughout the film. Rothrock, a real-life martial arts champion, brings authenticity and intensity to the role, with her fight scenes being some of the most memorable in the movie. Cynthia Rothrock’s Impact: Cynthia Rothrock was one of the few female action stars in the 1980s to gain recognition in a genre dominated by male leads. In No Retreat, No Surrender 2, she showcases her exceptional martial arts skills, particularly in hand-to-hand combat sc...

GEORGE SEGAL: THE HOLOCAUST, 1984.

GEORGE SEGAL:  THE HOLOCAUST , 1984 . Was the Holocaust “special”? George Segal’s extraordinary memorial proposes a line of inquiry strikingly different from the familiar exercise—at once useless and obscene—of comparing the Nazi murder machine to other mass exterminations in order to establish a hierarchy of historical horrors. Appropriately, the artist’s investigation takes the form of a perceptual itinerary: To see his work would seem to involve entering a private and protected area within a public space. The eleven figures in Segal’s tableau, surrounded on three sides by a poured-concrete palisade, have been installed on the summit of a slope in Lincoln Park in San Francisco, slightly below a parking area and just to the side of a road leading to the California Palace of the Legion of Honor. From the road we can see only a solitary standing figure. The work in its entirety is usually first viewed from the walkway above, a position from which, however, the whole group, though...

Before refrigerators existed, people would preserve products that needed to be kept cold, such as milk, by putting frogs in them.

Before refrigerators existed, people would preserve products that needed to be kept cold, such as milk, by putting frogs in them. In the past, each community had its own method of preservation. The ancient Russian and Finnish communities found a magnificent and very clever solution to this milk preservation: Throwing brown frogs called 'Rana temporaria' into milk... A scientific study conducted in 2013 proved that this method worked.  It was revealed that proteins such as Brevinin 1Tb synthesized from the skins of frogs (and other amphibians) restricted the life of some bacteria.  Thus, the Russians and Finns discovered, albeit through trial and error, that they could fight bacteria by adding proteins produced from the skins of frogs to their milk.

18 COSTLY MISTAKES THAT HUSBANDS MAKE

18 COSTLY MISTAKES THAT HUSBANDS MAKE 1. WORKING SO HARD AT YOUR JOB/BUSINESS BUT NOT IN YOUR MARRIAGE Men, your company, your career, and your business are growing and flourishing because you lead them; your marriage will grow and flourish when you lead it and dedicate time to it. 2. THINKING THAT FLIRTING WITH OTHER WOMEN IS NOT CHEATING You may not physically sleep with other women, but emotionally cheating is also unfaithfulness. Receiving nude images and having phone intimacy with other women is also cheating. Talking suggestively and attracting temptations is also cheating. If you are a flirt, flirt with your wife. If you claim your wife is too rigid, treat her well, and she will respond to your kinky ways. She also wants intimate pleasure and to feel wanted. 3. BEING GENEROUS OUTSIDE AND STINGY AT HOME Don't be the husband who quickly says yes when other people ask for help, for your time and your money, but stingy to your wife and child/children. Your family comes first. Do...

S*X AND FEELINGS

S*X AND FEELINGS A man can have s*x with a lady and still don't have any feelings for her, most men only need space to have s*x but majority of women need reason to have s*x. 90% of woman cannot have s*x without feelings, A man can travel for eight hours just to have s*x with a female and yet, not love her or even have any feelings for her.    S*x makes men act as if they are in love while they are not!! What they feel is lust, what they feel is what they see which is curves and a huge behind, go through a lady's silky skin thigh for a 5 minutes or less, ejac*late and forget. The eight hours travel sacrifice, gifts bought, hotel paid for and other expenses may seem to be coming from true love but they were all in the sacrifice for s*x and nothing more. The foolish thing is this, the majority of women would jump up inside them and conclude that this is the art of true love. So many woman are bought and blinded by materialistic things, yet miss the small little gestures that mon...

Your family doesn't know how much difficulties and pressure you go through in your daily life or in your job

- Your family doesn't know how much difficulties and pressure you go through in your daily life or in your job.  - And your work doesn't know the circumstances of your life and your home.  - Your colleagues, your friends, and loved ones will not understand the size of the new and old responsibilities that are above you.  - And your partner is always expecting unconditional love and support from you, he/she wont understand the amount of pressure you go through no matter how much you talk and explain to him/her. No one will understand what you're really going through and they most likely don't appreciate efforts.

Battle of Balikpapan (1945)

Battle of Balikpapan (1945) The  Battle of Balikpapan  was the concluding stage of Operation Oboe, the campaign to liberate Japanese-held British and Dutch Borneo. The landings took place on 1 July 1945. The Australian 7th Division, composed of the 18th, 21st and 25th Infantry Brigades, with a small number of Netherlands East Indies KNIL troops, made an amphibious landing, codenamed  Operation Oboe Two , a few miles north of Balikpapan. The Allied invasion fleet consisted of around 100 ships. The landing had been preceded by heavy bombing and shelling by Australian and US air and naval forces. The Allied force totalled 33,000 personnel and was commanded by Major General Edward Milford, while the Japanese force, commanded by Rear Admiral Michiaki Kamada, numbered between 8,400 and 10,000, of which between 3,100 and 3,900 were combatants. After the initial landing, the Allies secured the...

Bob Marley was once asked if there was a perfect woman. He replied: Who cares about perfection?

Bob Marley was once asked if there was a perfect woman. He replied: Who cares about perfection? Even the moon is not perfect, it is full of craters. The sea is incredibly beautiful, but salty and dark in the depths. The sky is always infinite, but often cloudy. So, everything that is beautiful isn't perfect, it's special. Therefore, every woman can be special to someone. Stop being "perfect", but try to be free and live, doing what you love, not wanting to impress others!

TODAY BIGGEST JOKE

1. You see those girls that eat alot without getting fat, the food goes directly to their attitude😏 very stubbørn set of people 😒 2. When a stīngy man is looking for a wife, any girl who asks him for money is not a wife material😂😂 3. You Think you are doing me" But you are doing yourself" if your Mom haven't told you such words, you are Adøpted 😂 4. There are only two✌️ nāked things that can kīll a man 1. Nāked wire 2. Nāked woman 😂😂😂☠️ They will not teach you this in school  🏃🏾‍♂️ 5. Have you noticed that after scratching your itchy anūs, the devil will always whisper, ''now smēll your fingers my child''😂 6. Wahala Dey for who no go school oooh... 😩 if not for sound Education, how will I know that a Baby Lizard 🦎 is cālled ‘LIZZY BABY’.🤣😂 7. Convincing a lady who came to visit you to leave the sitting room and enter the bedroom is a skill that should be added to a man CV.💀💀  it not easy😭 ©️ King Valentine ✍🏼 8. Allowing a guy who is not...